48 Laws emblem

Which Side of a Deal Should You Win First?

MMohamed El Hadri·9 min read
Which Side of a Deal Should You Win First?

Which side do you win first in a deal? The one that's bleeding. Not the side with the bigger cheque, not the side you like more, not the side that called you first. The side that's in more pain, right now, today. Win that side and the other one follows you without a pitch.

This is Law 20 of MIDDLEMAN: Win the Side That's Bleeding. It sits on the Grip floor, next to owning the customer and making yourself impossible to go around, because reading the pain correctly is what tells you where to put your effort first.

Every market has a side that's hurting more

Two sides never arrive at a deal equally desperate. Sometimes the buyer is desperate and the supplier can pick and choose. Sometimes there's a glut of supply and the buyer holds all the cards. The split is never 50-50, and it changes week to week, job to job.

I ran a maintenance company in London working for housing associations and letting agents. The same two sides sat either end of every job: the agent with a repair to sort and the subbie who'd do it. Some weeks the agent was desperate and the subbies had the pick of the work. Other weeks it flipped. Reading which side was bleeding that week decided where I put my attention first.

Why the bleeding side is where the leverage lives

A side in pain doesn't negotiate hard. A side in pain just wants the bleeding to stop. They'll pay faster, forgive a rough edge, and remember your name longer than the side that was never worried in the first place.

Find which side is in pain, and serve that side first.

Serve the comfortable side first and you've picked the easy, grateful-feeling job and left the real leverage on the table. The comfortable side already has options. They'll shop you against three competitors because nothing's forcing their hand. The bleeding side has no patience for that. They need the problem gone, and the person who makes it gone first wins the loyalty, not just the job.

The letting agent with no cleaner

Say a letting agent has four tenancies turning over this week and the cleaning crew they normally use has just dropped two of them. That agent is bleeding. They don't care about your rate card. They care that someone, anyone, reliable, can be there Thursday.

Show up for that agent this week and you've won more than one job. You've won the reason they call you first next time, because the day they were desperate, you were the one who answered. Compare that to chasing an agent who's perfectly happy with their current setup. You're competing on price against a supplier they already trust. The bleeding agent needed you to show up. That beats a rate card every time.

Read the pain before you read the brief

Most people price a job off the brief: square footage, scope, timeline. That tells you what the job is. It tells you nothing about who needs you more.

Before you quote, ask one question: who loses more if this doesn't get sorted this week? Sometimes it's the client, sitting on a complaint from a tenant. Sometimes it's the subbie, sitting on an empty week with the mortgage due. Whoever answers "me" first is the side to win first, because that's the side that will actually move on your terms.

  • A client chasing an emergency callout is bleeding harder than a client planning next quarter's maintenance schedule.
  • A subbie with an empty diary is bleeding harder than one booked solid for a month.
  • A buyer under a deadline is bleeding harder than a buyer just comparing quotes.

Once you've named the bleeding side, the second side is almost always easier than people expect. Solve the urgent problem and the calm side sees it solved and relaxes into the deal. You rarely have to chase both sides equally hard. You chase one, and the other watches you be the person who gets things done.

When both sides seem to be bleeding

Sometimes it looks like both sides are desperate at once: the client needs the job done yesterday and the subbie needs the cash yesterday too. That's not a tie. Look closer and one of them still has more options than the other.

The client with no cash flow but three competing contractors on speed dial has options. The subbie with an empty diary and a mortgage due Friday has none. Win the subbie first in that case, not because he pays you, but because he's the one who'll actually walk if nobody steadies him this week, and losing him costs you the job you were trying to save in the first place. The client, even desperate, is still choosing between you and the next name on the list. Serve whoever has the fewest other doors to knock on.

The cost of getting the order wrong

I've seen it both ways. Chase the comfortable side first because they're easier to talk to, and you've spent your best hours reassuring someone who was never going anywhere, while the bleeding side quietly rings the next number on their list. By the time you turn to them, the problem's solved and you've missed the moment that would have earned you their loyalty for free.

Get the order right and it compounds. The agent you saved on the worst week of their month doesn't shop you against competitors next time. The subbie you kept afloat during a quiet patch takes your call first when he's busy with better offers elsewhere. Neither of those outcomes shows up in the quote you sent. Both of them show up in whether your phone rings again without you having to chase it.

This isn't about picking favourites

Winning the bleeding side first doesn't mean you ignore the other one or treat them as less important. It means you sequence your effort where it buys the most trust for the least cost. The calm side still gets looked after. They just don't need convincing, because nothing is on fire for them yet.

Get this backwards and you spend your best energy reassuring someone who was never worried, while the person actually bleeding goes and finds whoever answers next. That's how a middleman loses a deal he should have owned outright: not through bad pricing, through bad reading.

Where to go next

Law 20 sits on the Grip floor of the 48 laws, alongside Law 19, Chase the Reputation Harder Than the Money, and Law 18, Feed Your Suppliers - the laws that decide whether both sides of a deal want to keep you in the middle of it. For how the gap between two sides sets your fee in the first place, read Law 5, The Wider the Gap, the Fatter the Toll.

Prefer to listen for the mechanics of this in practice? THE EDGE is a listening book on how money actually moves through a building business - who pays first, who waits, and what that tells you. First chapters free on ElevenReader, then $4.99.

Read which side is bleeding before you quote the next job, and win that one first. Start with THE EDGE on ElevenReader, free to begin.

which side to win first as a brokerwin the side thats bleedingmiddleman negotiation strategywhich side of a deal to serve firstMIDDLEMAN bookchase the bleeding sidesupply and demand leverage trades

Keep reading

The first laws of MIDDLEMAN, free in your inbox. No spam. Unsubscribe in one tap.